Reviews straight from our customers
Soft-baked, made from scratch since 2012, and loved across The Bahamas. Here’s what our customers say.
On Google
4.6 150+ reviews
Google
“These are the best cookies I have ever had in my life. This is not a joke, these are phenomenal!!! Please, whatever recipe you use for Birthday Cake and Cream Cheese RV, never stop using it. 1000/10. And I love the lady at the front desk.”
Google
“I’m now addicted 😍😍 The red velvet cookie stuffed with cream cheese is to do forrrr, omg this place is amazing.”
Google
“Best cookies on the island!! They are soft and moist, baked to perfection.”
Google
“Excellent cookies. I would eat a dozen cookies in one sitting. I had to slow down from eating so much 😀”
Google
“Always a great place to visit for delicious cookies. The presentation is always neat. There are always tasty seasonal treats… The staff is always friendly.”
On Facebook
92% recommend us across 588 Facebook reviews
“I’ve been ordering from The Cookie Caterer for the past 2 years now, and every time I’m pleased. They also have excellent customer service. I’d recommend them to anyone.”
“Softest cookies in Nassau. 10/10.”
“Ordered a massive box of assorted flavours as a Christmas treat for the students I tutor and my staff. They were delicious. Will definitely choose them next time.”
“I got a dozen cookies today and everything was awesome, especially the double chocolate ones. Will be buying again.”
“Soooft cookies. My favourite is the red velvet.”
“Their cookies are very soft and delicious! The lady who served me was very polite. I’ll definitely be back.”
“Best cookies… EVER! Who needs cake when you can have cookies that taste better than cake?”
“My baby’s birthday cookies were amazing. Good service too!”
“These cookies are crazy good, and friendly service as well.”
“The best cookies in town! Consistent, and always good service.”
“My order was perfect. Customer service was excellent! This company is going to go far.”
“Cookies are heaven.”
Visit the shop
295 Prince Charles Drive, Nassau
Monday to Saturday, 11am–6pm · closed Sundays and public holidays